South of Union Square logo
South of Union Square
Story
Spooky Sites

We delve deep into the ghost stories, murder plots, and haunted location lists to bring you the most thorough collection of New York City's spookiest spots! Check out the historic photographs of the city's most haunted sites, from Psycho-esque mansions to abandoned lunatic asylums.

How many have you visited? Proceed at your own risk!๐Ÿ’€๐Ÿ’€๐Ÿ’€

ByUrban Archive logoUrban Archive
Start
1
Fulton Avenue and 169th Street
Fulton Avenue and 169th Street icon

Fulton Avenue and 169th Street

We don't know much about this house, but doesn't it look like the perfect haunted mansion?
1
2
Madison Square Garden (Madison Square)
Madison Square Garden (Madison Square) icon

Madison Square Garden (Madison Square)

Few architects, when designing a building, imagine it becoming the spot of their murder, so it is must have been a shock for Stanford White to be shot on the roof of his own creation. Harry Kendall Thaw attacked White in what was called at the time: "The Crime of the Century" and still provokes controversy today.
2
3
Holy Cross Armenian Apostolic Church
Holy Cross Armenian Apostolic Church icon

Holy Cross Armenian Apostolic Church

Few looking at this church would it expect it to have been the site of a grizzly murder yet on Christmas Eve, 1933 that's exactly what happened. Leon Tourian, the archbishop of the Eastern Armenian Church for the United States had earned the ire of Armenian nationalists. Normally guarded, the archbishop was certain that no harm would come to him on such a holy day. This assumption proved false when, whilst walking down the aisle, Tourian was surrounded by assailants and stabbed to death.
3
4
116 Mulberry Street
116 Mulberry Street icon

116 Mulberry Street

In the corner of this photo can be spotted Umberto's Clam House, an old mob hangout. In 1972, shortly after the restaurant's opening, mob boss Joe Gallo, having decided to come in for a snack, was killed. Having been shot 5 times by two hitmen, Gallo stumbled out into the street and then died.
4
5
Octagon Tower
Octagon Tower icon

Octagon Tower

The Octagon Tower is the only surviving structure of the 1839 New York Lunatic Asylum, and it certainly looks the part of a creepy abandoned mental hospital in this ca. 1970s photograph.
5
6
Stuyvesant Polyclinic Hospital
Stuyvesant Polyclinic Hospital icon

Stuyvesant Polyclinic Hospital

Few gangsters were more infamous than Arnold Rothstein in Prohibition-era New York. "The Brain" had rigged the 1919 world series, was a skilled gambler, and had come to dominate the bootlegging gangs of New York. However, his failure to pay a large debt in a poker game caused Rothstein to be shot. Before he died in the Stuyvesant Polyclinic Hospital, Rothstein refused to answer questions about his shooting, he supposedly retorted "you stick to your trade, I'll stick to mine."
6
7
Lent-Riker Homestead
Lent-Riker Homestead icon

Lent-Riker Homestead

The oldest NYC house still occupied as a private residence, the 1654 building (with 1729 additions) sits next to a colonial cemetery, the final resting place of 132 Lent-Riker family members. An 1818 gravestone inscription reads, "Weep not my friends all dear, I am not dead but sleeping here; The debt is paid, the grave you see, Prepare for death and follow me.โ€
7
8
"House of Death"
"House of Death" icon

"House of Death"

Twentieth-century tenants of this building on West 10th Street claim to have seen the ghost of Mark Twain, who lived there briefly in 1900, as well as the spirits of no less than 20 other persons who have died in the nearly 175-year-old house.
8
9
Lefferts-Laidlaw House
Lefferts-Laidlaw House icon

Lefferts-Laidlaw House

In late December 1878, the residents of this Brooklyn home began experiencing mysterious happenings: doorbells ringing, violently rattling doors and a broken window. According to the NY Times reporting the police even got involved. After two weeks of the strangeness, the Times notes that the resident, Edward Smith, had banished the spirits with "a long and honest prayer."
9
10
12 Gay Street
12 Gay Street icon

12 Gay Street

This Gay Street address was once the home of corrupt Mayor Jimmy Walker's showgirl mistress and later a Prohibition-era speakeasy. Neighbors say they still can catch the spirits of flappers and the Gay Street Phantomโ€”a dapper gent in a cloak and top hatโ€”on the street at night.
10
11
Gustav Mayer House
Gustav Mayer House icon

Gustav Mayer House

Once owned by confectioner Gustav Mayer, this 10-bedroom Italianate Revival home might not be haunted but it certainly looks the part. ๐Ÿš๏ธ
11
12
Village Plaza Hotel
Village Plaza Hotel icon

Village Plaza Hotel

This seedy SRO hotel was the final address of 18-year-old Linda Fitzpatrick. A wealthy boarding school runaway, she was murdered, along with her hippie boyfriend, in 1969 during an LSD-fueled attack in the basement of an East Village flophouse.
12
13
Hell Gate Channel
Hell Gate Channel icon

Hell Gate Channel

The treacherous tidal strait known as Hell Gate is the site of scores of pre-20th century shipwrecks, owing to the dangerous rocks and sometimes violent converging currents. In 1904, it also played a part in the General Slocum disaster that killed more than 1000 women and children.
13
14
Belasco Theatre
Belasco Theatre icon

Belasco Theatre

David Belasco, the building's namesake, supposedly still haunts this 1907 theatre and its ongoing performances.
14
15
Chelsea Hotel
Chelsea Hotel icon

Chelsea Hotel

The Hotel Chelsea has had its fair share of grisly history. Most famously, is the murder of Nancy Spungen, girlfriend to Sid Vicious, who was stabbed to death in their room in 1978. Rumor has it that former residents have stuck around eternally, including Dylan Thomas and a grief-stricken Titanic survivor named Mary.
15
16
887 Columbus Avenue
887 Columbus Avenue icon

887 Columbus Avenue

The Hotel Endicott saw an unusually high occurrence of a disaster, scandal, murder in the early 20th century. In one case in 1909, after having been continually rebuffed by the object of her infatuation, an Endicott chambermaid visited his nearby apartment and drank acid before knocking on his door. She, of course, died from the poison.
16
17
New Amsterdam Theatre
New Amsterdam Theatre icon

New Amsterdam Theatre

Supposedly the ghost of Olive Thomas, a Ziegfield Follies girl who committed suicide in 1920, still haunts the New Amsterdam. Theatre employees greet her photograph, hung at every entrance, each morning to keep her spirit mischief to a minimum.
17
18
Washington Square Arch
Washington Square Arch icon

Washington Square Arch

๐Ÿ’€ Washington Square Park was once the site of the city's potter's field, a couple of local church cemeteries, and a hangman's gallows. In 2015 during water main work under the park, two burial vaults were discovered filled with largely intact wooden coffins and human remains.๐Ÿ’€
18
19
Hotel Algonquin
Hotel Algonquin icon

Hotel Algonquin

Best known as the daily meeting spot for a group of writers, critics and actors post World War I, stories say that members of the Round Table (also called the Vicious Circle) have stayed on at the hotel, including its most famous member Dorothy Parker.
19
20
12 West 23rd Street
12 West 23rd Street icon

12 West 23rd Street

In 1870 the wealthy stockbroker uncle of poet Emma Lazarus was bludgeoned to death in his mansion of 23rd Street. Though suspicion was cast on his wild, and sometimes unstable, 22-year-old son, the crime was never solved.
20
21
Merchant's House Museum
Merchant's House Museum icon

Merchant's House Museum

Gertrude Tredwell, the last family member to live in the house, died there in 1933 at age 93. Some say she remains. The Merchant's House Museum even offers candle-lit ghost tours to try and catch a glimpse.
21
22
Tweed Courthouse
Tweed Courthouse icon

Tweed Courthouse

The courthouse built by the efforts (legal and otherwise) of Tammany's Boss Tweed, was also the locations where he was convicted of embezzlement in a yet unfinished courtroom in 1873. The building's nightwatchmen have supposedly seen the man's spirit in the very same room.
22
23
Radio City Music Hall
Radio City Music Hall icon

Radio City Music Hall

One of the theatre impresarios who created Radio City Music Hall, Samuel "Roxy" Rothafel, supposedly still haunts the auditorium and his private apartment in the building.
23
24
Grand Central Terminal
Grand Central Terminal icon

Grand Central Terminal

A story from the Terminal's open year goes like this: passengers report seeing an anxious man saying that the train to hell was coming for him at midnight. At 12:00 a.m. the man vanished and a whistle was heard, despite the next train not scheduled until 12:05.
24
25
St. Mark's Church in-the-Bowery
St. Mark's Church in-the-Bowery icon

St. Mark's Church in-the-Bowery

The first structure on the land that is now occupied by the 1799 St. Mark's Church was a family chapel built by Peter Stuyvesant on his farm. Pegleg Peter, who is buried in a vault under the building, allegedly still roams the grounds.
25
26
Empire State Building
Empire State Building icon

Empire State Building

In 1947 a young woman named Evelyn McHale leaped to her death from the ESB and the photo of her after having landed on a limousine below was disseminated as a portrait of "the most beautiful suicide."
26
27
Dakota Apartments
Dakota Apartments icon

Dakota Apartments

The creepy setting for the 1968 horror classic "Rosemaryโ€™s Baby," the Dakota is also said to be haunted by ghosts of residents past. ๐Ÿ‘ป๐Ÿ‘ป๐Ÿ‘ป
27
28
85 West 3rd Street
85 West 3rd Street icon

85 West 3rd Street

Edgar Allan Poe lived here briefly while writing his supernaturally themed work, "The Raven." Though the home has been moved and gutted (only a single banister remains of the original structure), Poe apparently still makes his presence know.
28
29
White Horse Tavern
White Horse Tavern icon

White Horse Tavern

A favorite watering hole of writer Dylan Thomas, it was here that he boasted he has consumed 18 straight whiskeys (a number denied by the bartender), stumbled back to his hotel (Hotel Chelsea, also on this list), after which he became unresponsive. He later died at a hospital and according to regulars, still keeps tabs on his favorite table at the pub.
29
30
Morris-Jumel Mansion
Morris-Jumel Mansion icon

Morris-Jumel Mansion

The Morris-Jumel Mansion, much like the Merchant's House, is rumored to have some supernatural activity and they actively embrace it with regular ghost-hunting tours. ๐Ÿ”ฆ
30
31
St. Paul's Chapel
St. Paul's Chapel icon

St. Paul's Chapel

The cemetery at St. Paul's Chapel dates to 1697 and rumor has it that many of its inhabitants still haunt the place, including the headless spirit of 18th-century British actor George Frederick Cooke. Cooke died from alcoholism while performing on an American tour in 1811. He was supposedly decapitated postmortem after willing his head to science to pay his doctor bills.
31
32
Park Central Hotel
Park Central Hotel icon

Park Central Hotel

It was in 1957 at the barbershop of the Park Sheraton Hotel that Albert Anastasia, a mob boss, and notorious murderer, was shot to death by two men whilst sitting in the barbers' chair. Anastasia lunged at the killers, only to discover he was looking at their reflections in the barbershop mirror. The brazen killing appalled the public and the haircut killing became forever associated with the mob.
32
33
Housman House
Housman House icon

Housman House

The owner of this home was murdered by "a party of Jersey raiders" in 1784! ๐Ÿ”ช๐Ÿ”ช๐Ÿ”ช
33
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service