South of Union Square logo
South of Union Square
Story
Before Wegmans: Grocers of Downtown Brooklyn

Though the excitement of Wegmans coming to Brooklyn might seem like an anomaly, Brooklynites have always been quick to celebrate a good grocer or butcher. Here are two famed grocers that inspired fervor over the years.

ByCenter for Brooklyn History logoCenter for Brooklyn History
Start
1
156 Henry Street
156 Henry Street icon

156 Henry Street

Thee new H. C. Bohack Company store on Henry St. and Love Lane was so popular that at the time of its opening in 1943, it was cited by the Brooklyn Heights Association as "the best improvement on the Heights during the past year."
1
2
156 Henry Street
156 Henry Street icon

156 Henry Street

Founded by Henry. C. Bohack, a German Immigrant, Bohack's was a New York City chain of grocery stores. Offering everything from fresh meats and vegetables, Bohack founded his first store on Fulton Street in 1887, the business quickly expanding.
2
3
156 Henry Street
156 Henry Street icon

156 Henry Street

Going public in 1965, Bohack eventually grew too large, buying out other supermarkets and taking on large amounts of debt. Eventually, in 1977, Bohack went bankrupt and closed down.
3
4
The Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company
The Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company icon

The Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company

However, Bohack's wasn't the only Grocer to cause a stir amongst Brooklynites. The Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company was another New York brand, founded in 1859 by George Gilman. Initially a store for tea and coffee, the brand expanded into groceries and became the largest grocer in America.
4
5
173 Atlantic Avenue
173 Atlantic Avenue icon

173 Atlantic Avenue

What made the hundreds of shoppers (pictured here) line up for blocks outside the "A\&P at 173 Atlantic Avenue was the special sauce that made The Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company so famous. It was an innovative supermarket because it offered Americans a vast assortment of different options that weren't available at local grocers at a low cost. You went to A\&P because it had food you couldn't get anywhere else.
5
6
The Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company
The Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company icon

The Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company

However, even the once-dominant A\&P couldn't last forever. Highly leveraged from its acquisition of Pathmark, A\&P suffered during the Great Recession. In 2015, The Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company filed for Chapter 11 after 156 years in business and ceased operations.
6
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service