[General Exterminating Corp., southwest corner of Lawrence Street and Tillary Street.]
General Exterminating Corp., southwest corner of Lawrence Street and Tillary Street. 24 Lawrence Street, Lawrence Street side showing.
1959
[General Exterminating Corp., southwest corner of Lawrence Street and Tillary Street.]
General Exterminating Corp., southwest corner of Lawrence Street and Tillary Street. 24 Lawrence Street, Lawrence Street side showing.
General Exterminating Corp. at No. 24 Lawrence Street, July 26, 1959.
This two-story brick structure, long-since razed for the MetroTech development, sat the southwest corner of Lawrence and Tillary streets, a site formerly occupied by an 1830s-era church.
Built as the Second Baptist Church in 1834, the wood-frame structure was sold to the Free Presbyterian Church four years later. In 1845, that congregation elected to switch denominations, becoming Congregationalist. It is listed as a Congregational Methodist Church on an 1855 map.
In response to Brooklyn's growing Polish population, Bishop Loughlin recruited Father Joseph Niedzielski of Cincinnati to become the pastor of the diocese's first Polish parish. The Tillary Street church was known as St. Casimir's from 1875 to 1890, when the parish outgrew its modest sanctuary.
The humble church's next and final tenant was St. Michael the Archangel, a predominantly Italian parish. Al Capone, the infamous Chicago gangster, was born in Brooklyn and baptized at St. Michael's in January 1899.
In 1942, St. Michael's merged with nearby St. Edward's in Fort Greene, leaving the 108-year-old church vacant.