St. Michael's Protestant Episcopal Church, ca. 1915.

St. Michael’s parish was founded in 1807 as an outpost of the Trinity Church on Wall Street in Lower Manhattan. Bloomingdale, as the Manhattan Valley section of the Upper West Side was then known, was a largely rural district, close to the Hudson River and the summer country homes of Trinity pewholders. Accordingly, the first church was a simple wooden structure at the corner of 99th Street and Amsterdam Avenue. The second church, built in 1854, was another wooden structure in the Carpenter Gothic style.

The present St Michael’s church, a 1,500-seat Romanesque structure by Robert W. Gibson, was completed in 1891. The church features several works designed by Louis Comfort Tiffany, including a set of seven stained-glass lancet windows, a reredos mosaic in the Chapel of the Angels, and various decorative elements.

St. Michael’s was designated a New York City Landmark in April, 2016.