231-237 Second Avenue ca. 1900-1910

U.S. Senate and The W.M. Evarts are somewhat peculiar names for apartment buildings. But these two structures were called such after William Maxwell Evarts, a distinguished 19th-century lawyer, and politician. Evarts, who lived in a brownstone on the site during the 1850s when the area was quite fashionable, was Secretary of State under Rutherford B. Hayes and a United States Senator. Though Evarts would move his family out of the brownstone, he would continue to rent it and supposedly had great affection for the building. Following Evart's death, it was demolished and the pair of apartment buildings were erected. The New Yorker reported that "none of the family had anything to do with naming the buildings that are there now." Evart's grandson stated " I suppose The U.S. Senate got its name in honor of Grandfather's last public office, but the connection seems pretty thin. It was the style in those days to give apartment buildings fancy names, and the builders must have been desperate." Adding insult to injury, he added "drab-looking places, aren't they?"