South of Union Square logo
South of Union Square
Place
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church
157 Montague Street

Posts & Stories(8)

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church
Post

Forsythia in bloom at St. Ann & the Holy Trinity, Brooklyn Heights, April 7, 1961.
Churches, and Clubs, and Classrooms, Oh My! The History of Saint Ann's School image

Churches, and Clubs, and Classrooms, Oh My! The History of Saint Ann's School
Story

Though its name seems to suggest otherwise, Saint Ann's is a non-sectarian school known for its non-traditional education style. How it came to be named after a Saint comes from its eclectic history.
Morrell's Montague image

Morrell's Montague
Walk

John D. Morrell was a photographer who shot thousands of documentary photographs across Brooklyn between 1957-1974. Take a quick walk along Montague Street with Morrell from Cadman Plaza to the Promenade:
155 Montague Street image

155 Montague Street
Post

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church
Post

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity was built as The Church of the Holy Trinity by Brooklyn paper manufacturer Edgar Bartow, who wanted a magnificent edifice for the City of Brooklyn with pews that were rent-free. Bartow chose architect Minard Lafever to design the church and adjoining chapel and rectory, which are considered to be the finest achievement of Lafever's career. An important example of Gothic Revival architecture in America, the richly ornamented church is notable for its elaborately vaulted roof and extensive suite of stained glass windows by William Jay Bolton. St. Ann's pipe organ was built in 1925 by Ernest M. Skinner (Opus #524), and is the third instrument to be installed since the church opened in 1847. During the Cold War in the 1950s, there was dissension within the congregation which eventually led to the dissolution of the church in 1957. The building was closed and stood mostly vacant for more than a decade. In 1969, nearby St. Ann's Church, the oldest Episcopal congregation in Brooklyn moved four blocks into the Holy Trinity building. St. Ann's took the new name of St. Ann & the Holy Trinity in honor of the building's heritage. Today's parishioners continue the life of a body of faithful Episcopalians who have worshiped in Brooklyn for more than 240 years, first gathering during the American Revolution. Bishop Lawrence Provenzano designated the church as pro-cathedral during a festive Evensong service at St. Ann & the Holy Trinity on September 16, 2018.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church
Post

Church of St. Ann & the Holy Trinity, July 10, 1958. The Church of the Holy Trinity (as it was first known) is one of the masterpieces of Gothic Revival style in 19th century American ecclesiastical architecture. Minard Lafever's elaborate interior features a soaring nave with wood-frame plaster vaults, and more than 7,000 square feet of stained glass by William Jay Bolton. Today, Bolton’s organ loft window is on permanent exhibition in the American Wing of the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Lafever was commissioned by Edgar Bartow, a wealthy merchant who wanted to build the finest church in either Brooklyn or New York City. Bartow purchased eight lots from Hezekiah Pierrepont at the highest point of Brooklyn Heights. Construction began in 1847; when the church opened in 1848, it was the largest structure in Brooklyn. When the tower and spire were finished in 1867, it was, at 295 feet, the tallest building in either Brooklyn or Manhattan, beating Wall Street’s Trinity Church by 15 feet. The spire was taken down in 1906 due to structural instability. The Church of the Holy Trinity was the scene of a bitter McCarthy-era struggle. Rector John Melish and his son, Assistant Rector Howard Melish, were political progressives advocating for civil rights and for peaceful co-existence between the United States and the Soviet Union. Howard Melish chaired the National Council of American-Soviet Friendship, a target of Senator Joseph P. McCarthy's anti-Communist campaign. In 1949, the Church Vestry tried to oust the Melishes, whereupon the congregation voted 261 to 27 to remove the Vestry, which then sued to enjoin the congregation. In 1957, after a decade of struggle, the Episcopal Diocese of Long Island closed the church. The church stood vacant until 1969 when St. Ann’s parish, the oldest Episcopal congregation in Brooklyn, decided to relocate into the building from its church on nearby Livingston Street. In honor of the building’s origin, the parish took the new name, St. Ann & the Holy Trinity. In the intervening decade since its closure, the church had deteriorated severely. To assist in addressing the grave disrepair, the nonprofit St. Ann’s Center for Restoration and the Arts was established in 1983. During its residency at the church, it was instrumental in, among other things, stabilizing and/or restoring portions of the exterior, the facade, nave roof, and, notably, a majority of the Bolton stained glass windows, even as it successfully established its own performing arts program. Relocated to DUMBO in 2000, it is now known as St. Ann’s Warehouse.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church
Story

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity was built as The Church of the Holy Trinity by Brooklyn paper manufacturer Edgar Bartow, who wanted a magnificent edifice for the City of Brooklyn with pews that were rent-free.
MAS Brooklyn Survey image

MAS Brooklyn Survey
Story

Between 1954 and 1957, the Municipal Art Society surveyed historic buildings in all five boroughs to create a database of potential landmarks to preserve. Local residents and MAS staff compiled individual sheets devoted to about 200 buildings. Each sheet outlined the building’s date, location, and style and provided a description and a small photograph. This is the list of Brooklyn buildings.

Photos(49)

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Brooklyn: Clinton Street - Montague Street (1) Clinton Street, at the N. W. corner of Montague Street, showing the Holy Trinity Protestant Episcopal Church. The foundation for this edifice,of which Edgar John Barton was the builder, was begun in August 1844. The chapel opened for services on June 7, 1846, and the church on April 25, 1847. The steeple, which was erected in 1860, was removed in 1906. Two buildings (not in this view) at Nos. 122-124 Pierrepont Street were given to the parish by George Foster Peabody in 1905 and 1912, to be used as a guilderhouse and parish house. The rectory was purchased in 1897, and is at No. 126 Pierrepont Street. The church proper oost t175,000; the spire 275 feet in height, cost an additional 965,000. Minard Lefevre was the architect. About 1906 Eugene L. Armbruster Collection. (2) The Montague Street side of the church, viewing eastward. The 3y story building on the extreme left is the Trinity Club. March 1, 1929 P. L. Sperr (3) Another view of the church, vlewing northwestward across the roof of the Brooklyn Trust Company bu'lding (right foreground). March 1, 1929 P. L. Sperr
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Interior, Holy Trinity Church, from oil painting Oil painting of interior, Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street; nave, supporting pillars, and stained glass windows on left side.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Spire of Holy Trinity P. E.Church Rendering (drawing) of tower and portion of Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Members of Synod of New York and New Jersey Forty-seven men, most in clerical attire, standing in front of Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street; also: iron fence and two gas (?) lamps on each side of church doorway, pedestrian standing in left foreground, and residential buildings in left background.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Brooklyn: Montague Street - Clinton Street Montague Street, north side, at Clinton Street. A view of Holy Trinity Church (now known as St. Ann's Church)
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Holy Trinity Church, 1916 Exterior view of third, fourth, fifth and sixth panels (counting from east end) of south wall of Holy Trinity Church, Montague Street during construction of the BMT Fourth Avenue Subway Line. Camera located on stoop of #162 Montague Street opposite.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Holy Trinity Church, 1916 View showing condition of portion of exterior south wall and stonework on the lower part of two east bays of Holy trinity Church before underpinning along Montague Street was installed for construction of the BMT Fourth Avenue Subway Line. Camera set up on lumber pile along sidewalk about 15 feet south of south wall of church and 40 feet west of east baseline of Clinton Street.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Holy Trinity P. E. Church Interior, Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street. Altar and reredos (includes four small vases and representation of The Last Supper) with stained glass window behind, pulpit on right, chair and brass eagle on stand on left.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Brooklyn: Clinton Street - Montague Street (1) Clinton Street, at the N. W. corner of Montague Street, showing the Holy Trinity Protestant Episcopal Church. The foundation for this edifice,of which Edgar John Barton was the builder, was begun in August 1844. The chapel opened for services on June 7, 1846, and the church on April 25, 1847. The steeple, which was erected in 1860, was removed in 1906. Two buildings (not in this view) at Nos. 122-124 Pierrepont Street were given to the parish by George Foster Peabody in 1905 and 1912, to be used as a guilderhouse and parish house. The rectory was purchased in 1897, and is at No. 126 Pierrepont Street. The church proper oost t175,000; the spire 275 feet in height, cost an additional 965,000. Minard Lefevre was the architect. About 1906 Eugene L. Armbruster Collection. (2) The Montague Street side of the church, viewing eastward. The 3y story building on the extreme left is the Trinity Club. March 1, 1929 P. L. Sperr (3) Another view of the church, vlewing northwestward across the roof of the Brooklyn Trust Company bu'lding (right foreground). March 1, 1929 P. L. Sperr
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Fire, Holy Trinity Church Portion of facade of Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street, with ladder extended up to "balcony" level (two men on ladder, four men on ledge), parked automobiles, commercial (?) building on right, subway entrance in foreground, and several spectators on street. (Note: there is no indication of fire in the photograph.).
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

P. E. Trinity Church on Heights Portion of facade (stone) of Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street, with parked fire truck, ladder extending up to "balcony" level, many spectators, and policeman and horse in right foreground.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Brooklyn: Clinton Street - Montague Street (1) Clinton Street, at the N. W. corner of Montague Street, showing the Holy Trinity Protestant Episcopal Church. The foundation for this edifice,of which Edgar John Barton was the builder, was begun in August 1844. The chapel opened for services on June 7, 1846, and the church on April 25, 1847. The steeple, which was erected in 1860, was removed in 1906. Two buildings (not in this view) at Nos. 122-124 Pierrepont Street were given to the parish by George Foster Peabody in 1905 and 1912, to be used as a guilderhouse and parish house. The rectory was purchased in 1897, and is at No. 126 Pierrepont Street. The church proper oost t175,000; the spire 275 feet in height, cost an additional 965,000. Minard Lefevre was the architect. About 1906 Eugene L. Armbruster Collection. (2) The Montague Street side of the church, viewing eastward. The 3y story building on the extreme left is the Trinity Club. March 1, 1929 P. L. Sperr (3) Another view of the church, vlewing northwestward across the roof of the Brooklyn Trust Company bu'lding (right foreground). March 1, 1929 P. L. Sperr
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Stained glass windows, Holy Trinity Episcopal Church] : \[six images] Image represented is one of a related set (CHUR 0250, CHUR 0251, CHUR 0249, CHUR 0248, CHUR 0247), some of which may also be described in this new record; Six stained glass windows in Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street, representing: Adam and Eve being driven from the Garden of Eden, Abraham about to sacfirice Isaac, the birth of Jesus, Jesus arriving in Jerusalem on Palm Sunday, Jesus, Peter and another apostle in row boat, and the crucifixion of Jesus.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Stained glass windows, Holy Trinity Episcopal Church] : \[six images] Image represented is one of a related set (CHUR 0250, CHUR 0251, CHUR 0249, CHUR 0248, CHUR 0247), some of which may also be described in this new record; Six stained glass windows in Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street, representing: Adam and Eve being driven from the Garden of Eden, Abraham about to sacfirice Isaac, the birth of Jesus, Jesus arriving in Jerusalem on Palm Sunday, Jesus, Peter and another apostle in row boat, and the crucifixion of Jesus.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Stained glass windows, Holy Trinity Episcopal Church] : \[six images] Image represented is one of a related set (CHUR 0250, CHUR 0251, CHUR 0249, CHUR 0248, CHUR 0247), some of which may also be described in this new record; Six stained glass windows in Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street, representing: Adam and Eve being driven from the Garden of Eden, Abraham about to sacfirice Isaac, the birth of Jesus, Jesus arriving in Jerusalem on Palm Sunday, Jesus, Peter and another apostle in row boat, and the crucifixion of Jesus.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Stained glass windows, Holy Trinity Episcopal Church] : \[six images] Image represented is one of a related set (CHUR 0250, CHUR 0251, CHUR 0249, CHUR 0248, CHUR 0247), some of which may also be described in this new record; Six stained glass windows in Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street, representing: Adam and Eve being driven from the Garden of Eden, Abraham about to sacfirice Isaac, the birth of Jesus, Jesus arriving in Jerusalem on Palm Sunday, Jesus, Peter and another apostle in row boat, and the crucifixion of Jesus.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Stained glass windows, Holy Trinity Episcopal Church] : \[six images] Image represented is one of a related set (CHUR 0250, CHUR 0251, CHUR 0249, CHUR 0248, CHUR 0247), some of which may also be described in this new record; Six stained glass windows in Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street, representing: Adam and Eve being driven from the Garden of Eden, Abraham about to sacfirice Isaac, the birth of Jesus, Jesus arriving in Jerusalem on Palm Sunday, Jesus, Peter and another apostle in row boat, and the crucifixion of Jesus.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Stained glass windows, Holy Trinity Episcopal Church] : \[six images] Image represented is one of a related set (CHUR 0250, CHUR 0251, CHUR 0249, CHUR 0248, CHUR 0247), some of which may also be described in this new record; Six stained glass windows in Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street, representing: Adam and Eve being driven from the Garden of Eden, Abraham about to sacfirice Isaac, the birth of Jesus, Jesus arriving in Jerusalem on Palm Sunday, Jesus, Peter and another apostle in row boat, and the crucifixion of Jesus.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Church of Holy Trinity : cross of red roses Cross of roses (red?) in yard of Holy Trinity Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street; iron fence along front and side, portion of church facade behind, and doorway at right of, cross.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Trinity Church Interior, Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street. Many rows of pews, altar, reredos with stained glass window behind, pulpit in front, right, chair and brass eagle on stand in front, left, flag on each side, and chandeliers.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Holy Trinity Episcopal Church] Facade and tower (stone) of Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street, with iron fence along front and side, street light and street sign in center foreground, pedestrians, woman pushing baby carriage, parked automobile, commercial (?) building on far right, and intersecting streets.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Trinity Church Interior, Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street. Altar, reredos (includes four small vases and representation of The Last Supper) with stained glass window behind, pulpit and American flag on right, chair, brass eagle on stand, and flag on left, and several rows of pews.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Interior of Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Brooklyn Heights] Image represented is one of a related set (CHUR 0261), some of which may also be described in this new record; Nave of Holy Trinity Church at Montague and Clinton Streets, looking toward reredos and stained glass window of altar; pews in foreground empty; images nearly identical.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Vandalism on the Heights Caption: "Vandalism on the Heights--Bulletin board of the Episcopal Church of the Holy Trinity, Clinton and Montague Sts., shown defaced with strip bearing the words, 'Commie Preachers.'" On left, sign: "Church open daily from 9 am. - 5 p.m. Come in, \[r]est and pray."
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Holy Trinity Church, Church of St. Anne
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Holy Trinity Episcopal Church Facade and tower (stone) of church with iron fence along front and side, pedestrians, parked and moving automobiles, street light and street sign in center foreground, commercial (?) building on far right, and intersecting streets. Caption: "Holy Trinity Episcopal Church--the 107-year-old Gothic American structure at Clinton and Montague Sts. has been classed among structures of great local importance which should be preserved in the borough by the Municipal Art Society."
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Northwest corner of Montague Street and Clinton Street.] Northwest corner of Montague Street and Clinton Street, with Church of the Holy Trinity on the corner and the Long Island Historical Society just beyond.
155 Montague Street image

155 Montague Street

\[Foffes Restaurant, Montague Street.] Foffes Restaurant, Montague Street. The round objects are pumpkins - part of a Halloween decoration.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[View of Montague Street, looking northwest from corner of Clinton Street.] View of Montague Street, looking northwest from corner of Clinton Street. Portion of Church of the Holy Trinity at right.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[View from window of Long Island Historical Society looking south towards Montague Street. ] View from window of Long Island Historical Society looking south towards Montague Street. A portion of Church of the Holy Trinity at right.
155 Montague Street image

155 Montague Street

Foffes restaurant, Montague Street.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Monday evening from window at #156 Montague Street.] Monday evening from window at #156 Montague Street. Picketing in front of Trinity Club at time of controversy over closing.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Trinity Club (right, center) & Foffe Restaurant (left) on north side of Montague Street, between Henry Street and Clinton Street, Brooklyn Heights.] Trinity Club (right, center) & Foffe Restaurant (left) on north side of Montague Street, between Henry Street and Clinton Street, Brooklyn Heights.
155 Montague Street image

155 Montague Street

\[North side of Montague Street.] North side of Montague Street between Clinton + Henry Streets looking northwest. Taken from window of #156 Montague Street.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Clinton Street and Montague Street.] Clinton Street and Montague Street. Holy Trinity Church and Long Island Historical Society in background. View looking north along Clinton Street.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Forsythia by Church of the Holy Trinity.] Forsythia by Church of the Holy Trinity, 1570 Montague Street, Brooklyn 1, N.Y.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Forsythia by Church of the Holy Trinity.] Forsythia by Church of the Holy Trinity, 157 Montague Street.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Church of the Holy Trinity.] Church of the Holy Trinity, 157 Montague Street., showing forsythia BMT Subway entrance center.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Forsythia, Church of the Holy Trinity.] Forsythia, Church of the Holy Trinity, corner of Montague Street Clinton Street.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Forsythia by Church of the Holy Trinity.] Forsythia by Church of the Holy Trinity, Montague Street.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[View of Montague Street.] View of Montague Street (north side) from 3rd floor window of #156 Montague Street.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Church of the Holy Trinity.] Church of the Holy Trinity, Montague Street Clinton Street.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[St. Ann's and the Holy Trinity Church, 157 Montague Street.]
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Montague Street.]
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Brooklyn: Court Street - Montague Street A general view west from the Temple Bar Building located at the S.W. corner of Court and Montague Streets, showing the Brooklyn Heights section of Brooklyn between Remsen Street (extreme left) and Fulton Street (extreme rights). In the foreground is the Episcopal Church of the Holy Trinity at the N.W. corner of Montague and Clinton Streets. At the left background is the Hotel Bossert at the S.E. corner of Montague and Hicks Streets. Also shown is the Manhattan skyline and at the right a part of the Brooklyn Bridge. Note the junction of the East and North Rivers with Upper New York Bay. The New Jersey skyline vaguely appears in the left background. Brown Brothers. Neg. #5027
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Holy Trinity Episcopal Church] Reproduction: aerial view of Brooklyn Heights and vicinity with steeple of Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street, in center. Brooklyn Bridge is in background.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Holy Trinity Church
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

Church of the Holy Trinity Facade and tower (stone) of Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street, with iron fence along front and side, two church signs (one attached to facade at left of doorway, one attached to fence in foreground), street light in foreground, and parked automobiles and commercial (?) building on far right.
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church image

St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church

\[Holy Trinity Episcopal Church] Facade and steeple of Holy Trinity Episcopal Church, Montague Street and Clinton Street, with iron fence along front and side, residential buildings on both sides, and intersecting streets.
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service