South of Union Square
Menu
Place
Share
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Posts & Stories
(3)
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Post
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown, 1924. The First Presbyterian Church of Newtown is the oldest church in the borough of Queens. The congregation was established by a community of English settlers who had moved into the area in the 1650s and constructed an all-purpose thatched roof building that also served as school and town hall. In the first decades, the community was a mix of English dissidents, French Huguenots, Dutch Reformed, Church of England adherents, and others. In 1715 the church received its charter and was officially named the First Presbyterian Church of Newtown. The church was an early advocate of religious freedom in America and was the site of much strife during the American Revolution. The Presbyterian community was vehemently opposed to British rule and suffered at the hands of British soldiers, who jailed church members and used the church as a prison before demolishing it. The church building seen here was erected only four years after the end of the war. Finished in 1787, the "Old White Church" saw the community through considerable growth during the 19th century. The surrounding graveyard (which predated this structure by decades) was the final resting place of generations of community members. In 1891 a wealthy parishioner willed $70,000 for the construction of a new building. The new brownstone church was completed across Queens Boulevard in 1895. This wood-frame structure continued to be used for church functions until it was heavily damaged by a fire in 1928, and razed one year later. The cemetery remained even after the removal of the structure; the parish sold the land in 1958. At that time, some unknown number of graves were unearthed and removed to Evergreens Cemetery in Brooklyn. Today an apartment building occupies the lot where once the 18th-century church and cemetery stood.
US250 Queens Walks: Newtown
Walk
"Newtown" was the name of Elmhurst for more than 200 years when it was changed in 1897, and many places in town still use that name. But in Colonial times, Newtown also referred to a much larger township, which stretched all the way to the waterfront and what is now Long Island City. You may need to hop on a bus to complete this tour of Revolutionary-era sites in Newtown!
Small Cemeteries
Story
This is a collection of the smaller burial places that dot the landscape of the five boroughs. They are family burial plots and church graveyards, some full of 300-year-old grave markers and some with no monuments at all, some squished between storefronts and major thoroughfares and others hidden behind homes and walls. While most remain extant (if not always accessible), some have been lost to time and development.
Photos
(34)
View fullscreen
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown on Queens Boulevard east of Broadway, Elmhurst, Queens, New York City, undated (ca. 1882-1919).
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown on Queens Boulevard east of Broadway, Elmhurst, Queens, New York City, undated (ca. 1882-1919).
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Old Newtown Presbyterian Church The old Newtown Presbyterian Church. The church burned on October 14, 1928, and was gone by May 1929. hand written on back of print: Old Presb ch built 1787-91 old square pews removed 1836 reshingled 1915 northside Queens Boulevard east of Broadway Elmhurst Newtown 1922
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Old Newtown Presbyterian Church The old Newtown Presbyterian Church. The church burned on October 14, 1928, and was gone by May 1929. Image is faded. hand written on back of print: Old Presbyterian church built 1787-91 The original Presb. Meeting house built 1671 stood on the opposite site of road nearly opposite the present Old church. Was occupied by Episcopal 1903-1708 First edifice on northside (site ofthe present old church) was built 1716 but was not fully completed ntil 1741 the site was donated by Jonathan Fish 1715. The first edifice on this site stood while Revolutionary War used as guardhouse and prison by British + after demolished Newtown 1922
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Old Newtown Presbyterian Church The old Newtown Presbyterian Church. The church burned on October 14, 1928, and was gone by May 1929. Image is faded. hand written on back of print: Newtown Pres Church Newtown Jan 1923
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens Boulevard and 55th Road North east corner of Queens Boulevard. The old Newtown Presbyterian Church, on the right, burned on October 14, 1928, and was gone by May 1929. hand written on back of print: old Presbyterian Church northside Queens Boulevard east of Broadway opposite site of "corner house" Elmhurst on left Victor Weber old + new house + Hardware both ne. corner Queens Boulevard + Broady directly opposite the corner house stood Moores Grocery Store where was kept the village Post Office the store + an adjoining block of frame houses were swept away by fire Van Wincle Kept PO church destroyed before Oct 14, 1929 Newtown Jany 1923
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Old Newtown Presbyterian Church The old Newtown Presbyterian Church. The church burned on October 14, 1928, and was gone by May 1929. Image is faded. hand written on back of print: old Presbyterian Church northside Queens Boulevard east of Broadway Elmhurst on left Victor Weber old + new Hardware store Damaged by fire Oct 14, 1928 gone May 1929 all gone May 1, 1931 Newtown Jany 1923
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Old Newtown Presbyterian Church The old Newtown Presbyterian Church. The church burned on October 14, 1928, and was gone by May 1929. Image is faded. hand written on back of print: Old Presbyterian church northside Queens Boulevard east of Broadway Elmhurst destroyed by fire Oct 14 1928 torn down 1929 Newtown 1924
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Avenue Queens Boulevard, north side, between Broadway (left) and Fifth-fifth Ave. (right) showing in a set of two views the old Presbyterian Church of Newtown. Next to it on the left is the Victor Weber hardware stores, old and new. See other views. Jan. 1923. Views 1 and 2 Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Road Queens Boulevard, north side, between Broadway and 55th Rd., showing 4 views of the old Presbyterian Church of Newtown which was destroyed by fire on Oct. 14, 1928. In May 1929 it was demolished. See other views. Oct. 18, 1928. Views 1,2 3 and 4. Eugene L. Armbruster Collection.
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Road Queens Boulevard, north side, west from 55th Rd. to Broadway in 4 views showing the old Presbyterian Church of Newtown. See other views. View No. S shows an eastward view from Broadway. The original church was erected in 1671 and stood on the south side of the road opposite this durch. It was occupied by Episcopalians from 1703-1708. The Chapel of this church was removed and used as a Sabbath School. 1922 Views 1 and 2. View 3 Jan 1923. View 4: Oct. 18, 1928. Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Road Queens Boulevard, north side, west from 55th Rd., to Broadway showing in 4 views the destNuction caused by fire to the Presbyterian Church of Newtown. See other views. Oct. 18, 1928. Views 1,2,3 and 4. Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Road Queens Boulevard, north side, west from 55th Rd., to Broadway showing in 4 views the destNuction caused by fire to the Presbyterian Church of Newtown. See other views. Oct. 18, 1928. Views 1,2,3 and 4. Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Avenue Queens Boulevard, north side, between Broadway (left) and Fifth-fifth Ave. (right) showing in a set of two views the old Presbyterian Church of Newtown. Next to it on the left is the Victor Weber hardware stores, old and new. See other views. Jan. 1923. Views 1 and 2 Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Avenue Oueers Boulevard, north side, west of Fifty-fifth Ave., to Broadway, showing in 4 views the Old Presbyterian Church and Cemetery of Newtown. The Church was destroyed by fire in May 1929. iee other views. The rest of the buildinaein this view were all demolished by Mar. 1, 1931. This churcn was erected in 1787 on site of a former one destroyed by the British during the Revolutionary Var. Dr. John P. Knox was pastor from 1855 to 1882. At this time square pews with little doors were installed. Jan. 1923. Views 1 and 2 View 3: July 1925 View 4: Oct. 1928. Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Avenue Oueers Boulevard, north side, west of Fifty-fifth Ave., to Broadway, showing in 4 views the Old Presbyterian Church and Cemetery of Newtown. The Church was destroyed by fire in May 1929. iee other views. The rest of the buildinaein this view were all demolished by Mar. 1, 1931. This churcn was erected in 1787 on site of a former one destroyed by the British during the Revolutionary Var. Dr. John P. Knox was pastor from 1855 to 1882. At this time square pews with little doors were installed. Jan. 1923. Views 1 and 2 View 3: July 1925 View 4: Oct. 1928. Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Road Queens Boulevard, south side, west from near 55th Road, shoowLng old frame houses and the First Presbyterian Church of Newtown. The first house (left) was owned by P. Rapelye. the second by G. Rapelye, and the one nearest the church by Burns, in 1873. The houses are being demolished. View 3 shows a closer view of the Burns house: view 4 is from 55th Road and shows the houses gone. The two hor es in view 4 do not appear in the other views. View 1: December 27, 1922 Views 2,3: December 29, 1922 View 4: February 28, 1924 Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Avenue QQueens Boulevard, 1rarth side, west of Fifty-fifth Ave. to Broadway, showing in two views an old Presbytorian Church and Cemetery, partially destroyed by fire in 1928. IIt was demolished in May 1929. February 11, 1924. View 2: October 18, 1928. Eugene L. Armbruster Collection.
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Road Queens Boulevard, north side, west from 55th Rd. to Broadway in 4 views showing the old Presbyterian Church of Newtown. See other views. View No. S shows an eastward view from Broadway. The original church was erected in 1671 and stood on the south side of the road opposite this durch. It was occupied by Episcopalians from 1703-1708. The Chapel of this church was removed and used as a Sabbath School. 1922 Views 1 and 2. View 3 Jan 1923. View 4: Oct. 18, 1928. Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Road Queens Boulevard, south side, west from near 55th Road, shoowLng old frame houses and the First Presbyterian Church of Newtown. The first house (left) was owned by P. Rapelye. the second by G. Rapelye, and the one nearest the church by Burns, in 1873. The houses are being demolished. View 3 shows a closer view of the Burns house: view 4 is from 55th Road and shows the houses gone. The two hor es in view 4 do not appear in the other views. View 1: December 27, 1922 Views 2,3: December 29, 1922 View 4: February 28, 1924 Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Road Queens Boulevard, north side, between Broadway and 55th Rd., showing 4 views of the old Presbyterian Church of Newtown which was destroyed by fire on Oct. 14, 1928. In May 1929 it was demolished. See other views. Oct. 18, 1928. Views 1,2 3 and 4. Eugene L. Armbruster Collection.
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Road Queens Boulevard, north side, between Broadway and 55th Rd., showing 4 views of the old Presbyterian Church of Newtown which was destroyed by fire on Oct. 14, 1928. In May 1929 it was demolished. See other views. Oct. 18, 1928. Views 1,2 3 and 4. Eugene L. Armbruster Collection.
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Road Queens Boulevard, south side, west from near 55th Road, shoowLng old frame houses and the First Presbyterian Church of Newtown. The first house (left) was owned by P. Rapelye. the second by G. Rapelye, and the one nearest the church by Burns, in 1873. The houses are being demolished. View 3 shows a closer view of the Burns house: view 4 is from 55th Road and shows the houses gone. The two hor es in view 4 do not appear in the other views. View 1: December 27, 1922 Views 2,3: December 29, 1922 View 4: February 28, 1924 Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Road Queens Boulevard, south side, west from near 55th Road, shoowLng old frame houses and the First Presbyterian Church of Newtown. The first house (left) was owned by P. Rapelye. the second by G. Rapelye, and the one nearest the church by Burns, in 1873. The houses are being demolished. View 3 shows a closer view of the Burns house: view 4 is from 55th Road and shows the houses gone. The two hor es in view 4 do not appear in the other views. View 1: December 27, 1922 Views 2,3: December 29, 1922 View 4: February 28, 1924 Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Avenue Cueens Boulevard, north side, between 55th Avenue and Broadway, whowing the Presbyterian First Church of Newtown, erected in 1787. Tt was damaged by fire in 1928. A new, granite edifice was erected for the congregation in 1893, directly across the street from this structure. View 1: Arthur White About 1920 View 2: P. L. Sperr June 7, 1927
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 54th Avenue Queens Boulevard, south side, between Fifty-forth and Fifty-fifth Avenues, showing in three views the First Presbyterian Church of Newtown. Views one and two show the front and rear of the the edifice. John Goldsmith Payntor who died in 1891 left the parish sufficient money for the erection of the store structure. The cornerstone was laid July 6, 1893 and the edifice was dedicated hay 5, 1895. View No. 3 is taken from a point south of Justice Avenue, between Fifty-fifth and Fifty-second Avenues, viewing south and shows in the foreground the old Church and cemetery on the north side of the Boulevard between Fifty-fifth Avenue and Broadway. 1922 Views 2&3: May 1923 Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Road Queens Boulevard, north side, between Broadway and 55th Rd., showing 4 views of the old Presbyterian Church of Newtown which was destroyed by fire on Oct. 14, 1928. In May 1929 it was demolished. See other views. Oct. 18, 1928. Views 1,2 3 and 4. Eugene L. Armbruster Collection.
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Road Queens Boulevard, north side, west from 55th Rd. to Broadway in 4 views showing the old Presbyterian Church of Newtown. See other views. View No. S shows an eastward view from Broadway. The original church was erected in 1671 and stood on the south side of the road opposite this durch. It was occupied by Episcopalians from 1703-1708. The Chapel of this church was removed and used as a Sabbath School. 1922 Views 1 and 2. View 3 Jan 1923. View 4: Oct. 18, 1928. Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Avenue Oueers Boulevard, north side, west of Fifty-fifth Ave., to Broadway, showing in 4 views the Old Presbyterian Church and Cemetery of Newtown. The Church was destroyed by fire in May 1929. iee other views. The rest of the buildinaein this view were all demolished by Mar. 1, 1931. This churcn was erected in 1787 on site of a former one destroyed by the British during the Revolutionary Var. Dr. John P. Knox was pastor from 1855 to 1882. At this time square pews with little doors were installed. Jan. 1923. Views 1 and 2 View 3: July 1925 View 4: Oct. 1928. Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Road Queens Boulevard, north side, west from 55th Rd., to Broadway showing in 4 views the destNuction caused by fire to the Presbyterian Church of Newtown. See other views. Oct. 18, 1928. Views 1,2,3 and 4. Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Road Queens Boulevard, north side, west from 55th Rd. to Broadway in 4 views showing the old Presbyterian Church of Newtown. See other views. View No. S shows an eastward view from Broadway. The original church was erected in 1671 and stood on the south side of the road opposite this durch. It was occupied by Episcopalians from 1703-1708. The Chapel of this church was removed and used as a Sabbath School. 1922 Views 1 and 2. View 3 Jan 1923. View 4: Oct. 18, 1928. Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Road Queens Boulevard, north side, west from 55th Rd., to Broadway showing in 4 views the destNuction caused by fire to the Presbyterian Church of Newtown. See other views. Oct. 18, 1928. Views 1,2,3 and 4. Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
First Presbyterian Church of Newtown (1787)
Queens: Queens Boulevard - 55th Avenue Oueers Boulevard, north side, west of Fifty-fifth Ave., to Broadway, showing in 4 views the Old Presbyterian Church and Cemetery of Newtown. The Church was destroyed by fire in May 1929. iee other views. The rest of the buildinaein this view were all demolished by Mar. 1, 1931. This churcn was erected in 1787 on site of a former one destroyed by the British during the Revolutionary Var. Dr. John P. Knox was pastor from 1855 to 1882. At this time square pews with little doors were installed. Jan. 1923. Views 1 and 2 View 3: July 1925 View 4: Oct. 1928. Eugene L. Armbruster Collection
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
Open Map