98 Third Avenue Building Date : 1839 Original Use : Residential Original Owner : Caleb Bartlett Original Architect : Unknown Description & Building Alterations Lot 31 is occupied by a mixed-use four-story building, built as a single-family residence in 1839 for Caleb Bartlett. The facade is similar to those belonging to nos. 92-96, except this building has a double window with a shared lintel and sill at the top story. A 1872 alteration permit indicates that the building had been utilized as a dwelling with a ground floor store and would become a three-family dwelling with a new storefront.

100 Third Avenue Building Date : 1837-39/2012 alt. Original Use : Industrial Original Owner : Ebenezer Pray Original Architect : Unknown Description & Building Alterations Formerly a four-story, 19th-century building, the facade was completely refaced and an extensive rooftop addition was built between 2009 and 2012. The now seven-story building features a metal facade. In the past this lot held many different functions. In the 1830s, it composed part of was a factory owned by Ebenezer Pray along with Lots 28 and 29. The lots were divided by 1865 and Lot 30 was used as a saloon. By 1899, it was converted into lofts and a concert hall. During the 1900s, different theater companies occupied the space: first the Comet, and then the Lyric Theater in 1936. In the 1960s-70s, it was called the Jewel Theater, known for playing all-male films. In the 1980s it was the Bijou, which played XXX fares until city officials had it closed in 1989.

100 Third Avenue Built about 1880, the Lyric Theatre began as a restaurant and was converted into a music hall before its 1910 renovation as one of New York’s earliest motion picture houses. Originally holding 274 seats, the theater doubled its seating in 1923 in response to the growing taste for movie-going. By the 1930s, the Lyric’s clientele consisted chiefly of transients from the Bowery, a few blocks to the south, who paid ten cents to see two features (one a western), a newsreel, and a short subject.